Global Law Experts Logo

Find a Global Law Expert

Specialism
Country
Practice Area

Awards

Since 2010, the Global Law Experts annual awards have been celebrating excellence, innovation and performance across the legal communities from around the world.

Clarification on GFSC mandate

posted 5 years ago

The Court of Appeal of Guernsey has recently provided clarification on the mandate of the island’s financial regulator, the Guernsey Financial Services Commission (GFSC). The case provides practitioners, industry and of course, the GFSC with helpful guidance on a number of areas, including:

  • Whether the GFSC has the power to issue time-determinate prohibition orders under the various regulatory laws;
  • Whether it was reasonable and proportionate to issue a public statement and if so, what would be the appropriate content of such a public statement; and
  • Whether the Senior Decision Maker (SDM) process can be considered an independent and impartial tribunal for the purposes of Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR).

Background

Y was a chartered accountant who was employed by “Licensee X” who held a fiduciary license. Eventually, Y became a controller of Licensee X. Whilst employed by Licensee X, Y also operated as a sole trader providing accountancy services separately from the business of Licensee X.



However, in the course of working for Licensee X, Y also began to offer the service of incorporating companies for clients, who were not clients of Licensee X, and without ensuring that correct customer due diligence had been sourced and stored with, or outside of, Licensee X. It was alleged that this had been done using Licensee X’s systems during office hours without their permission or knowledge. 

Y began to think he may be in breach of the regulatory laws and in particular, the Criminal Justice (Proceeds of Crime) (Legal Professionals, Accountants and Estate Agents) (Bailiwick of Guernsey) Law, 2008. At this point, he  made an initial disclosure to the GFSC’s Authorisation’s Unit. The GFSC then commenced a lengthy investigation into the matter which  resulted in a referral  to the GFSC’s Enforcement Division.

Upon the matter being referred to an  SDM, the process followed the various steps outlined in the GFSC’s Decision-Making Process Relating to the Use of Enforcement Powers, dated October 2017. This culminated in a Final Notice being issued by the SDM against Y.

The sanctions imposed by the SDM were, inter alia:

1. Orders pursuant to each of the suite of Regulatory Laws prohibiting Y, for a period of four  years, from (i) holding the position of director, controller, partner, manager, financial adviser, general representative or authorised insurance representative; and (ii) acting as Money Laundering Reporting Officer or Compliance Officer within a person licensed under any of the Regulatory Laws;

2. A discretionary financial penalty of £13,000; and

3. The issuance of a public statement.

Y then made a statutory appeal to the Royal Court disputing the findings of the SDM on a total of nine  grounds of appeal.

Royal Court findings at first instance

Taking the three points of appeal listed above, the Royal Court determined the following:

Time-determinate prohibition orders

It had been assumed by the GFSC, industry and the Royal Court that the GFSC did, in fact, have the power to issue time-determinate prohibition orders. The established practice of the GFSC had always been to issue prohibition orders in line with the severity of the alleged offence.



In previous statutory appeals, the Royal Court had upheld such orders as being lawful. However, the Deputy Bailiff held that upon a correct interpretation of the various Regulatory Laws, the GFSC was not afforded that power.



Thus, in the case of Y, the time-determinate prohibition order given by the SDM was ultra vires. In coming to this decision, the Deputy Bailiff reasoned that from a literal and strict interpretation of the regulatory laws, the regulator was not provided with the ability to issue such orders.

The Deputy Bailiff also sought guidance from the practice of the FCA in the UK and the regulator in Jersey. In both of these jurisdictions, prohibition orders are given for an indefinite period with an indication of when the regulator would consider an application for reinstatement.

To the Deputy Bailiff this made sense since a finding that a person is not fit and proper (which is required in order to issue a prohibition order), necessitates a binary choice – one is either fit and proper or one is not. The expiry of time in and of itself does not cure the deficiency of being found not fit and proper. Essentially, there is no automatic rehabilitation to allow one to be back in the fit and proper camp again.

Public statements

Another weapon in the armoury of the GFSC in enforcement actions is the issuance of a public statement. Often, this is the most damaging for individuals in terms of their personal and professional reputations; especially so in a small jurisdiction such as Guernsey.



In the case of Y, the appellant appealed whether given the findings of the SDM in his or her Final Notice, the issuance of a public statement was proportionate.

Y also appealed the content of the public statement in that it contained information which was either irrelevant or superfluous and that the length of the statement at eleven pages was gratuitous.

In terms of the former, the Deputy Bailiff held that under the circumstances, the issuance of a public statement against Y was warranted. However, in terms of the appeal as to the statement’s content, the Deputy Bailiff found in favour of Y. In doing so, the judge reasoned the following:-

  • Context is permitted;
  • It must be a factual notice in order to protect the public as consumers and act as a deterrent to others. It should be limited to what was actually found by the SDM but importantly, it cannot be a substitute for the SDM’s reasoning and cannot follow too closely that reasoning contained within the SDM’s Final Notice;
  • The decision to issue a public statement necessarily entails a balancing act between the need to protect the public and the reputation of the Bailiwick whilst protecting the individual’s rights under Article 8 ECHR which protects one’s rights to private and family life.
The SDM enforcement process and Article 6

Initially, Y argued that the SDM process was not an independent and impartial tribunal as the GFSC appointed SDM is an organ thereof, not thus not fully independent.

Y therefore claimed that his Article 6 rights under the ECHR had been violated. Although Y eventually dropped this ground of appeal, the Deputy Bailiff thought it important enough to address within the Y decision. In obiter dicta, the question of whether the SDM process was actually Article 6 compliant was answered in the affirmative, with the Royal Court deciding that:-

there is no requirement for every body deciding such matters to be an independent and impartial tribunal provided there is a right of appeal to a court of full jurisdiction to hear the matter. If so, then not only is any breach of Article 6 purged but it prevents such a breach from occurring in the first place“.

Thus, if there were any defects at the GFSC level regarding Article 6 ECHR, these are necessarily cured by the right of statutory appeal to the Royal Court.

The findings of the Guernsey Court of Appeal

Not all issues canvassed by the Royal Court at first instance were insisted upon by the parties at the Court of Appeal. However, in relation to the question as to whether the GFSC had the power to issue time determinate prohibition orders, the Court of Appeal emphatically ruled that it does.

In reaching this conclusion, the Court of Appeal considered the actual language of the statutes in question and determined the following:-

  • In considering a power to impose a sanction, that power should admit the imposition of some lesser sanction and that in cases where there is no express provision to the contrary within the legislation granting that power, a prohibition order “need not be a blanket prohibition” and “that a statutory provision giving a power to impose a penalty or sanction will normally include as part of the power a power to do a lesser thing…”. Thus, by implication, the power to do the greater implies the power to do the lesser.


  • As regards the Royal Court looking to other jurisdictions for guidance on how they approach prohibition orders, the Court of Appeal held that no help can be gained by doing so since these regulators operate under different legislation and regulatory framework. Interestingly in obiter dicta, the Court of Appeal remarked that in relation to the practices of these other regulators they “had serious misgivings about the position they have taken“. It remains to be seen whether these other regulators will review their approach to prohibition orders in light of the Court of Appeal’s remarks.


  • And lastly, in terms of the interpretation of the words ‘prohibit’ or ‘prohibiting’, the Court of Appeal ruled that contrary to the Deputy Bailiff’s reasoning at first instance, there can be no rationale for interpreting those words to be necessarily restricted to prohibition without limitation of time. As for the Deputy Bailiff’s point that a prohibition for a specified period necessarily implies that the authority considers that the affected person should have returned to a state of being fit and proper, the Court of Appeal held that the “specification of the period does not fetter the authority’s hands; any further breaches will lead to further orders”.   

Comment

The Y decisions serve as a valuable reminder that regulators must act within their statutory powers and that the Courts are there to keep them in line should that be necessary. By appealing the decision of the SDM to the Royal Court, Y was able to secure successes on a number of grounds against the GFSC, most notably, in relation to the GFSC’s practice of issuing public statements.



In deciding that the public statement in Y’s case went too far, the GFSC was provided judicial guidance on the form and content of public statements going forward. This should be welcomed by the GFSC and industry alike.  

The Y decision also provided clarity on whether the GFSC SDM process was Article 6 ECHR compliant. Although often complained about by those going through the enforcement process, that the relationship between the GFSC and the SDM is too  close (the idiom “judge, jury and executioner springs to mind), the Court decisively affirmed its compliance by citing the individual’s right to statutory appeal to the Royal Court.



This right appeal cures any defect as to procedure at the GFSC level and thus preserves the individual’s right to a fair and impartial tribunal. Again, this issue was not considered by the Court of Appeal.

Finally, the Court of Appeal resolutely confirmed that contrary to the  findings of the Royal Court at first instance, the GFSC did indeed have the power to issue time determinate prohibition orders.



Such a finding will of course be welcomed by the GFSC given that their past practice has now been vindicated. It will also be welcomed by industry at large given that wrongdoers will no longer be facing indefinite prohibitions, which are arguably more draconian.



It is also certainly arguable that some power has been taken out of the GFSC’s hands, whereby once the time has been spent, the individual’s prohibition lapses.



By allowing the GFSC to review a prohibition after the passing of a certain amount of time, in order to determine whether an individual is then fit and proper, , this necessarily imparts power to the regulator and implies a presumption that the individual is not fit and proper. Essentially, the burden is on the individual to prove that they should no longer be prohibited.



Now with prohibition orders lapsing after a certain period, there is a necessary presumption that the individual is no longer unfit and improper once the time has been spent, with the burden on the regulator to determine whether the individual is unfit and improper to be a licensee.      

Author

Find the right Legal Expert for your business

The premier guide to leading legal professionals throughout the world

Specialism
Country
Practice Area
LAWYERS RECOGNIZED
0
EVALUATIONS OF LAWYERS BY THEIR PEERS
0 m+
PRACTICE AREAS
0
COUNTRIES AROUND THE WORLD
0

Join

who are already getting the benefits
0

Sign up for the latest advisor briefings and news within Global Advisory Experts’ community, as well as a whole host of features, editorial and conference updates direct to your email inbox.

Naturally you can unsubscribe at any time.

Online Casino Reviews

  • Freeroll Poker Tournaments For Real Money
  • Australian Online Casino Real Money
  • Best Slot App To Win Real Money
  • Online Casino Real Money Australia
  • Best Paying Online Pokies
  • Wizard Of Oz Online Slots
  • All Slots Casino Mobile
  • Best Online Poker App Real Money
  • Best Online Casino To Play Roulette
  • Is Online Casino Legal
  • Online Casino That Accepts Paypal
  • Play Roulette For Real Money
  • Slot Apps To Win Real Money
  • Real Money Slots Online Usa
  • Safe Online Casino
  • Wizard Of Oz Slots
  • Real Online Pokies Nz
  • Biggest Online Casino In The World
  • Online Casino Pay With Paypal
  • Online Casino That Accept Paypal
  • Online Casino Canada Real Money
  • 3 Card Poker Online Real Money
  • Online Slots Real Money Canada
  • Best Online Poker Sites For Real Money
  • Real Money Poker App Android Usa
  • How To Make Money From Online Casino Bonuses
  • Real Money Poker App Iphone
  • How To Play Blackjack Online For Real Money
  • Best Slots To Play
  • Top 10 Online Pokies
  • Best Poker Apps Real Money
  • Online Casino Legal
  • Best Payout Online Casino Uk
  • Win Money Online Slots
  • Online Poker Nj Real Money
  • How To Win Online Slots
  • Casino Gaming License
  • Play Real Pokies Online
  • Blackjack Sites For Real Money
  • Real Money Casino Games For Android
  • Best New Online Slots
  • Flaming 777 Slots Games
  • Online Blackjack With Live Dealers
  • How To Play Online Slots
  • Facebook Casino Games Real Money
  • Online Casino With No Minimum Deposit
  • How To Beat Online Slots
  • Online Casino License
  • The Big Payback Slots
  • Royal Vegas Online Casino Withdrawal
  • Online Casino Minimum Deposit 5
  • Online Pokies Real Money Australia
  • Las Vegas Usa Online Casino
  • Real Money Poker App Android
  • Wheel Of Fortune Slots
  • Game Of Thrones Slots
  • Online Poker Real Money Usa Legal
  • Best Online Casino European Roulette
  • Blackjack Online Real Money Paypal
  • Online Video Poker Real Money Usa
  • How To Create An Online Casino
  • Lucky Nugget Online Casino Mobile
  • How To Withdraw Money From Online Casino
  • Platinum Play Online Casino Download
  • Online Casino For Usa Players
  • Best Online Casino Usa Real Money
  • Online Roulette Real Money Usa
  • Best Real Money Poker Sites
  • Android Slots Real Money
  • How To Start An Online Casino Business
  • How To Start An Online Casino
  • How To Start An Online Gambling Site
  • Best Online Casino For Blackjack
  • Play Baccarat Online For Money
  • Online Pokies New Zealand
  • Best Slots To Play At Golden Nugget
  • Slots Of Vegas Online Casino
  • Best Online Pokies Site
  • How To Beat Online Roulette
  • New Zealand Online Pokies
  • Online Poker Mobile Real Money
  • Which Online Slots Payout The Most
  • Is Online Casino Legal In India
  • Online Casino Software For Sale
  • Best Online Casino For Craps
  • Hard Rock Casino Slots
  • Win Real Money Online Pokies
  • Online Casino With Highest Payout Percentage
  • Poker Apps With Real Money
  • Online Roulette Real Money Review
  • Full Tilt Poker Real Money
  • Online Casino 5 Dollar Minimum Deposit
  • Online Roulette With Real Money
  • Best Online Roulette For Real Money
  • I Migliori Casino Online Italiani
  • Best Payout Online Slots
  • How To Play Baccarat Online
  • Play Casino Card Game Online
  • Play Blackjack Online For Real Money
  • Best Paying Online Slots
  • Casino License Cost
  • Online Poker Real Money California
  • Safe Online Casino Australia
  • Online Roulette Australia Real Money
  • Online Poker Real Money Texas
  • Online Roulette Real Money Paypal
  • Online Slots Australia Real Money
  • Golden Nugget Online Casino Review
  • Casino Games To Win Real Money
  • Online Pokies Australia Real Money
  • Online Gambling Blackjack Real Money
  • Win Real Money Playing Slots
  • How To Win Roulette Online
  • Aristocrat Pokies Online Real Money
  • Hollywood Casino Online Slots
  • Play Online Keno For Real Money
  • What's The Best Online Casino
  • Triple Double Diamond Slots
  • Play Roulette Online With Real Money
  • Roulette Online For Real Money
  • Play Roulette Online Real Money
  • Best Online Pokies Real Money
  • Big Red Pokies Online
  • How To Win At Online Blackjack
  • What Is The Best Online Roulette Site
  • Real Money Online Pokies
  • Spin To Win Slots
  • Ruby Slots Online Casino
  • Wheel Of Fortune Online Casino
  • Spin Palace Flash Casino Online
  • Online Poker Real Money App
  • Online Casino With Paypal Deposit
  • How To Win At Online Roulette
  • Can You Win Real Money On Slot Apps
  • Is Ignition Casino Safe
  • Online Casino Blackjack Real Money
  • Online Casino Win Real Money Usa
  • How To Make Money Online Casino
  • Online Casino Real Money Reviews
  • Slot Games To Win Real Money
  • Jackpot City Online Casino Download
  • Online Pokies Real Money
  • Casino War Online Real Money
  • Online Casino No Minimum Deposit
  • Play Wheel Of Fortune Slots Online
  • Best Online Casino Game To Win Money
  • Online Casino Without Wagering Requirements
  • Online Slots For Real Money Usa
  • Legal Online Casino Australia
  • How Do Online Slots Work
  • Best Online Casino For Us Players
  • Online Play Casino Roulette Game
  • Online Blackjack Real Money Australia
  • Real Casino Games Real Money Online
  • Online Slot Machines Real Money Paypal
  • The Best Online Casino For Roulette
  • What Online Casino Pays Out The Most
  • Start Your Own Online Casino
  • Legal Online Casino
  • Online Live Roulette Casino Game
  • Playing Blackjack Online For Real Money
  • Online Penny Slots Real Money
  • Best Online Blackjack For Money
  • How To Win Online Roulette
  • Real Money Poker Sites Usa
  • Best Time To Play Slots
  • Online Keno For Real Money
  • Best Payout Online Slots Uk
  • Online Slots Real Money Reviews
  • Best Online Pokies Nz
  • What States Allow Online Gambling
  • Best Real Money Poker App
  • Online Slots To Win Real Money
  • Real Money Slots App Iphone
  • Jackpot City Flash Casino Online
  • Ignition Casino Legit
  • All Star Slots Casino
  • How To Play Online Casino
  • Real Time Gaming Slots
  • Online Video Poker Real Money
  • How To Play Roulette Online For Money
  • How To Win On Online Slots
  • Age Of Gods Slots
  • Online Real Casino Money Games
  • Best Online Slots To Play
  • Online Poker California Real Money
  • Is Jackpot City Casino Legit
  • How To Win At Online Slots
  • Play Poker For Real Money
  • Safe Online Pokies Australia
  • Best Way To Play Slots
  • How To Play Casino Online
  • Play Online Roulette For Money
  • Online Casino Australia Real Money
  • Which States Allow Online Gambling
  • Play Keno Online Real Money
  • How To Win Online Blackjack
  • Online Blackjack With Real Dealers
  • How To Open Online Casino
  • What Are The Best Online Slots To Play
  • Big Win Casino Slots
  • Spin Palace Online Casino Australia
  • Best Slots To Win On
  • Casino Slots Win Real Money
  • Slots Magic Online Casino
  • Blackjack Online For Real Money
  • Slot Machine App Win Real Money
  • Online Casino Not Paying Out
  • Slots That Pay Out Real Money
  • Online Pokies Australia Reviews
  • Online Casino Minimum Deposit 1
  • Jackpot City Online Casino Review
  • Live Dealer Baccarat Online Casino
  • Online Casino Apps For Android
  • Online Casino Paypal Deposit Australia
  • Online Casino With Live Dealer
  • How To Play Blackjack Online
  • Slots To Win Real Money
  • Wheel Of Fortune Online Slots
  • Play Quick Hit Slots Online
  • Can You Count Cards In Online Blackjack
  • Palace Of Chance Online Casino
  • How To Play Roulette Online
  • Good Slots To Play
  • Which Online Casino Pays Out The Most
  • Heart Of Vegas Casino Slots
  • Best Online Casino For Canadians
  • Australian Online Pokies Real Money
  • Mohegan Sun Online Casino Nj
  • Online Casino Live Games Best Uk
  • Best Online Casino Australia Reviews
  • Play Pokies Online Real Money
  • Best Online Casino For Usa Players
  • How To Win Online Casino
  • Play Blackjack For Real Money
  • Best Slots On Bovada
  • Online Keno Real Money Usa
  • Online Slots Real Money Paypal
  • Best Poker Sites For Real Money
  • Safe Casino Sites
  • The Best Online Slots
  • Play Keno For Real Money
  • Real Online Pokies Australia
  • Queen Of The Nile Slots
  • Mummys Gold Casino Online Casino
  • Play Keno Online For Real Money
  • Best Poker Websites Real Money
  • Lucky Nugget Online Casino Download
  • Best Online Casino For Roulette
  • Play Roulette For Money Online
  • Video Slots Mobile Casino
  • Best Time To Play Online Slots
  • Best Real Money Online Poker
  • Play Blackjack Online With Friends
  • Play Baccarat Online For Real Money
  • Is Silver Oak Casino Legit
  • Big Fish Casino Real Money
  • Can You Win Real Money On Caesars Slots
  • Game Of Thrones Slots Casino
  • Best Online Slots Payout Percentage
  • Play Online Pokies For Real Money
  • Play Pokies Online Australia
  • High 5 Casino Real Slots
  • The Best Online Pokies
  • Online Pokies That Accept Paypal
  • Heart Of Vegas Slots
  • How To Play Online Roulette
  • Best Poker App Real Money
  • Best Online Casino Fast Payout
  • Best Slots At Wind Creek Casino
  • Online Casino 10 Minimum Deposit
  • Play Roulette Online For Money
  • Us Real Money Poker Sites
  • How To Win In Online Casino
  • Best Online Pokies Australia Review
  • Where To Play Roulette Online For Real Money
  • How To Beat Online Casino Slot Machines
  • Highest Payout Online Slots
  • Best Paying Online Casino Slots
  • Golden Tiger Online Casino Review
  • Online Casino With Live Dealers
  • Play Roulette Online For Real Money
  • Best Slots To Play At Casino
  • Slot Machine Games Win Real Money
  • Most Popular Online Casino Games
  • Casino Slots App Real Money
  • Online Casino Real Money Canada
  • Online Real Money Pokies
  • Online Roulette Game Real Money
  • Online Casino Roulette Real Money
  • Best Place To Play Roulette Online
  • Online Casino Book Of Ra Paypal
  • Online Blackjack With Real Money
  • Play Online Blackjack For Real Money
  • Is There A Slot Machine App For Real Money
  • Royal Vegas Online Casino App
  • Best Casino Slots To Play
  • Most Popular Online Slots
  • Best Way To Win At Slots
  • Slots You Can Win Real Money
  • Play Roulette Online Real Money Usa
  • Online Casino Real Money Paypal
  • Online Casino Australia Legal
  • Treasures Of Troy Slots
  • Online Casino For Us Players
  • Where Can I Play Blackjack Online For Real Money
  • Online Casino Paypal Book Of Ra
  • Online Roulette For Real Money
  • Best Online Blackjack Real Money
  • Poker App For Real Money
  • Jackpot Magic Slots Facebook
  • Best Online Casino Real Money Usa
  • Best Online Casino New Zealand
  • The Four Kings Casino And Slots
  • How To Play Slots Online
  • Best Online Pokies Australia
  • Usa Online Slots Real Money
  • Real Money Casino Android App
  • Online Slot Machines That Pay Real Money
  • Online Pokies Real Money Nz
  • Online Pokies Real Money App
  • Play Igt Slots Online
  • Best Casino Slots To Win Money
  • Online Casino Business For Sale
  • Play N Go Slots
  • Poker Apps For Real Money
  • Lucky Slots Real Money
  • All Slots Online Casino
  • Best Online Pokies Real Money Australia
  • Online Pokies Win Real Money
  • Best Online Casinos For Roulette
  • Pay Slots For Real Money
  • Best Online Poker Real Money
  • Slots App Win Real Money
  • Play Online Roulette For Real Money
  • Is Ignition Casino Legit
  • Wheel Of Fortune Slots Online
  • Lotsa Slots Real Money
  • Video Poker Online Real Money
  • Online Slots Usa Real Money
  • Play Blackjack Online Real Money
  • Jackpot City Online Pokies
  • Video Slots Online Casino
  • Is 888 Casino Legit
  • Online Slot Games That Pay Real Money
  • Prepaid Visa Card Online Casino
  • How To Stop Online Gambling
  • Best Slots To Play Online
  • Online Blackjack For Real Money
  • Slot Apps For Real Money
  • Mobile Slots Win Real Money
  • Newsletter Sign Up

    About Us

    Global Advisory Experts is dedicated to providing exceptional advisory services to clients around the world. With a vast network of highly skilled and experienced advisors, we are committed to delivering innovative and tailored solutions to meet the diverse needs of our clients in various jurisdictions.

    Contact Us

    Stay Informed

    Join Mailing List

    GAE