Canada’s biggest trading partner has always been the United States. Indeed, as of 2022, five times more trade with the United States than with its next-largest partner, the European Union, accounts for two-thirds of Canada’s overall volume of international trade. While China and Mexico were strong competitors for the title of United States’ top trading partner in 2023, Canada still holds that position. Because of the strong economic connections between the two border nations, it is typical for companies in one to have suppliers and clients in the other.

If your Canadian company deals with American suppliers, you can receive an invitation to fill out Form W-8BEN-E. This form helps American businesses document the tax status of their international suppliers and is required for U.S. withholding tax reasons. A Canadian company that does business with suppliers in the United States may be subject to U.S. tax laws that control the reporting and taxation of income.

One important document that American companies frequently request from their Canadian counterparts is Form W-8BEN-E, which is used by non-U.S. organizations to confirm that they are not subject to certain withholding taxes. This form assists American businesses in making sure that, when paying foreign corporations, they are adhering to IRS regulations.

Businesses in Canada that are categorized as active foreign financial entities (NFFEs) can verify their status as foreign entities by completing this form, provided that they are not involved in any financial activity that would require them to comply with more stringent tax reporting or withholding regulations.

In order to ensure smooth cross-border operations, Canadian firms can reduce needless withholding taxes on payments received from U.S. suppliers by correctly completing the W-8BEN-E. This article will explain how to correctly complete IRS Form W-8BEN-E and discuss the tax ramifications of business profits for an active non-financial foreign entity (NFFE) from Canada. We’ll talk more about what makes an active NFFE later on.

American Withholding Tax Implications for Canadian Business Profits

The terms described in the tax treaty between the U.S. and Canada will determine whether your company is subject to tax responsibilities in the U.S. On the basis of a few presumptions, which are outlined in detail below, this article will analyze Form W-8BEN-E.

Our first assumption is that your business was formed entirely in Canada and not at all in the U.S. This kind of company would be considered a tax resident entirely in Canada under Article IV.3(a) of the Canada-US tax treaty. According to this categorization, the company is presumably mostly taxable in Canada and is not responsible for paying taxes in the U.S.

Generally speaking, a Canadian tax resident is normally solely responsible for taxes paid within Canada. Nevertheless, in some cases, the business can be subject to U.S. taxes. Profits from a permanent establishment (PE) in the U.S. are one example of such a situation. The treaty states that the U.S. can only tax the share of commercial earnings that can be linked to this PE.

According to definitions, a permanent establishment is the specific location where trade is done. Many places are covered by this concept, such as a factory, workshop, mine, branch, office, and site of management. As per the provisions of Article VII.1 of the tax treaty, the United States would not have the right to tax the income of your Canadian company if it does not have any permanent location elsewhere.

It is important, therefore, to take into account scenarios in which your business may work with US-based partners or subcontractors when conducting business. In these situations, there may be a chance to argue that these partners or subcontractors function as your company’s dependent agents in the U.S., which might result in the establishment of a permanent presence there. A person must fulfill a number of requirements in order to be deemed as a dependent agent, chief among them being the ability to sign contracts on your company’s behalf.

The United States generally cannot tax the earnings of your business if your U.S. partners or subcontractors operate independently, which means they do not have the power to bind your company to contracts. This instance illustrates the broad rule that, for tax purposes, a temporary enterprise cannot be established only by independent contractors.

The ramifications of these definitions and linkages must always be kept in mind when conducting cross-border company activities. The type of relationships you have and the power partners or agents in the U.S. are given can have a big impact on your tax liabilities.

Your Canadian company should normally continue to be free from U.S. taxation on its commercial profits as long as it does not open a permanent location in the U.S. and as long as your partners and subcontractors operate independently. Consequently, minimizing possible tax obligations may be achieved by upholding distinct operating boundaries and being aware of the connections you make in the U.S.

Completing Form W-8BEN-E

When filling out Form W-8BEN-E, please follow these guidelines:

Part I: Identification of Beneficial Owner

• Line 5: If your company qualifies as an active non-financial foreign entity (NFFE), check the box for “Active NFFE.”
• Line 9: Enter your CRA Business Number in Line 9b, which is designated for the Foreign Tax Identification Number (TIN).

Part III: Claim of Tax Treaty Benefits

• Line 14: Select option “a” and specify “Canada.”
• Line 15: In this section, enter “VII.1” for the article reference, “0” for the exemption amount, “business profits” to describe the type of income, and state, “the beneficial owner does not carry on business through a permanent establishment situated in the U.S.”

Part XXV: Active NFFE

• Line 39: Check the box indicating “I certify,” provided that your entity meets the following criteria: (i) it is not classified as a financial institution, (ii) it earned less than 50% of its gross income from passive sources (such as dividends, interest, rents, royalties, annuities, etc.) in the previous calendar year, and (iii) it holds less than 50% of its assets that generate or are held to generate passive income.

Finally, don’t forget to complete Part XXX: Certification to finalize your form.

After completing the form, provide it to your U.S. customers—also known as the withholding agents. Never send it to the IRS.

Pro Tax Tips: Consult Experienced Canadian Tax Lawyers for Form W-8BEN-E

It is advisable to obtain the advice of knowledgeable Canadian tax lawyers while completing Form W-8BEN-E. Your business profits won’t be subject to withholding tax from the United States if the company is entirely Canadian-based and doesn’t conduct operations through a permanent establishment (PE) there. If your business meets the requirements to be classified as an active non-financial foreign entity (NFFE), completing Form W-8BEN-E is simple.

It is imperative to acknowledge that the advice furnished below is predicated on certain suppositions that might not correspond with your distinct situation. If your entity is categorized as a financial institution or a passive non-financial foreign entity, the issue becomes more complicated. Additionally, the laws may be very different if you are a U.S. PE and make profits, or if the revenue in question does not qualify as company earnings.

Consulting experienced Canadian tax lawyers in these situations may be extremely helpful. To make sure you are aware of your responsibilities and possible liabilities, they may assist you in navigating the complexities of the tax treaty between the United States and Canada. With regard to filling out Form W-8BEN-E correctly and any other standards you might need to meet, their experience can offer clarification.

In addition, tax experts may provide explanations on other pertinent paperwork and laws that can be applicable to your case, helping you stay clear of possible trouble.

If your NFFE is operational and you do not conduct business in the United States, completing Form W-8BEN-E may be reasonably easy. However, you should speak with knowledgeable tax experts to make sure you comply with all applicable regulations and to get guidance that is particular to your goals.

Frequently Ask Questions:

What factors decide whether a Canadian business’s profits are subject to U.S. taxes?

A Canadian company that was founded solely in Canada is subject to U.S. taxes on earnings obtained through a permanent establishment (PE) in the U.S., following the terms of the tax treaty between the U.S. and Canada. A company’s commercial profits are not subject to U.S. taxation if it does not have a PE in the U.S.

When would a Canadian company be able to classify U.S. partners or subcontractors as PEs?

Subcontractors or partners in the United States may be considered PEs of a Canadian corporation if they function as dependent agents for the business, as demonstrated, for example, by having the power to sign contracts on the business’s behalf. This is a high threshold, though, and generally speaking, the U.S. is not allowed to tax the commercial profits of a Canadian corporation when it operates autonomously.

What happens if you don’t follow the rules of withholding taxes in the United States?

Significant penalties, such as having U.S. income withheld at the highest tax rate and incurring legal ramifications, may arise from breaking U.S. withholding tax requirements. In order to prevent expensive errors, it is imperative that Canadian firms comprehend their responsibilities.

What is the significance of Form W-8BEN-E, and what does it mean?

Foreign entities can verify their status for U.S. tax purposes by submitting Form W-8BEN-E. It supports the claim of advantages under a relevant tax treaty and, if satisfied, shows that the entity is exempt from U.S. withholding tax on specific categories of income.

How can a Canadian company avoid having its revenues subject to withholding tax in the United States?

A Canadian company should make sure it doesn’t have a permanent establishment in the United States in order to avoid paying withholding tax in the United States. In addition, filing Form W-8BEN-E can assist in determining the foreign status of the company and enabling it to claim any relevant tax treaty advantages.

DISCLAIMER: All of the information contained in this article is general. It is only current as of the day it was posted. It might not be current as it has not been updated. It is not to be relied upon and does not provide legal advice. Each tax scenario is specific to its conditions and will not be the same as the examples given in the article. A professional Canadian tax lawyer should be consulted if you have any special legal issues.

Image by stockstockphoto via freepik