Global Law Experts Logo

Find a Global Law Expert

Specialism
Country
Practice Area

Awards

Since 2010, the Global Law Experts annual awards have been celebrating excellence, innovation and performance across the legal communities from around the world.

OPPO Directed to Pay "Pro-tem Security Deposit" for Nokia's Standard Essential Patents

posted 2 years ago

By Ranjan Narula and Suvarna Pandey

     

      • In a case concerning Standard Essential Patents (SEP), the Court has the power to pass a pro-tem order without an exhaustive exploration of the quantum of royalty payments.

      • If the negotiations between the parties fail, it does not mean that an implementer can continue to derive benefits by using the technology of the Standard Essential Patent proprietor in the interregnum without making any payments for such use.

      • A pro-tem security order intends to ensure maintenance of status-quo.

    Facts

       

        • The Present appeal was filed by the appellant-plaintiff (‘Nokia’) challenging the order dated 17th November 2022 passed by the Single Judge of the Delhi High Court dismissing Nokia’s application for the interim payments by Oppo. Nokia, in its lawsuit, sought directions asking a) Oppo to deposit interim security of an amount based on either the latest counteroffer made by it for a global licence of Nokia’s portfolio of Standard Essential Patents b) or of an amount equivalent to the royalty paid under the Agreement executed between the parties proportionate to the ratio of the number of devices sold by Oppo in India vis-à-vis the number of devices sold globally.

         

          • Oppo had 2018 secured a license to use Nokia’s Standard Essential Patents for a period of three years (until 30th June 2021). The 2018 Agreement was a cross-licence agreement for patents belonging to both parties.

          • Nokia argued that the 2018 Agreement did not include patents relating to the 5G standards, and considering that 52 percent of Oppo’s sales in India and 64 percent of its global sales consist of 5G devices, any new license fee would be substantially higher.

          • After the expiry of the 2018 Agreement, Oppo witnessed an unprecedented increase in the sale of its devices, and during the period between July 2021 and December 2022, it sold around 77 million devices in India without paying a single rupee in royalty to Nokia. It is also Nokia’s case that despite making efforts, including making itself available for discussions on the technical and economic fronts, Oppo refused to execute a fresh/second licence agreement.

          • Upon failure of execution of the fresh/second licence agreement between the parties, Nokia filed the lawsuit (being CS(COMM) 303/2021) for infringement of its three Standard Essential Patents by their manufacture, sale, etc., of the cellular devices which comply with 2G, 3G, 4G and 5G telecommunication standards by Oppo. These Standard Essential Patents are (i) Indian Patent No.286352 (IN’352), titled “System and Method for Providing AMR-WB DTX Synchronization,” (ii) Indian Patent No.269929 (IN’929), titled “Method Providing Multiplexing for Data Non Associated Control Channel” and (iii) Indian Patent No.300066 (IN’066) titled “Additional Modulation Information Signaling for High-Speed Downlink Packet Access” (hereinafter referred to as the ‘suit patents’).

        Court Ruling:

        The court ruling on a few important aspects concerning the ‘Pro-tem security deposit’ are covered below:

        FURNISHING OF PRO-TEM SECURITY IS THE IMPLEMENTER’S OBLIGATION IN THE NEGOTIATION PHASE ITSELF

           

          TO BALANCE THE EQUITIES, THE INDIAN COURT HAS THE POWER TO PASS A PRO-TEM ORDER, IF THE FACTS SO WARRANT

             

              • If the negotiations between the parties fail, it does not mean that an implementer can continue to derive benefits by using the technology of the Standard Essential Patent proprietor in the interregnum without making any payments for such use.

              • The Court also noted that nearly two years have elapsed since the institution of the suit, and not a ‘single farthing’ has been paid by Oppo. Consequently, to balance the equities between the parties, this Court has the power to pass a pro-tem order being a temporary arrangement without a detailed exploration of merits if the facts so warrant. 

              • The Court also relied on Ericsson Vs. Intex, CS(OS) 1045/2014   where the Delhi High Court Rules governing patent suits, 2022 has recognized the concept of pro- tem security and has held that the Courts have the power to pass deposit orders even on the first date of hearing if the facts so warrant. 

            A PRO-TEM SECURITY ORDER CAN NOT BE LINKED TO AN INJUNCTION

               

                • This Court opined that a pro-tem security order cannot be linked to an injunction order because, unlike an injunction order, it does not stop or prevent the manufacturing and sale of infringing devices. The intent of a pro-tem security order is to either ensure maintenance of status quo or to retain the Courts’ power and ability to pass appropriate relief at the time of the decision of the injunction application. In the facts of the present case, the pro-tem security order does not confer any advantage upon Nokia as it only balances the asymmetric advantage that an implementer has over a Standard Essential Patent holder. 

                • The Court further directed Oppo to deposit the money in Court, which will be reimbursed to Oppo should it succeed at the interim or final stage.

              The Court allowed Nokia’s appeal to set aside the challenged order. The Court also directed the respondent to deposit the ‘last paid amount’ attributable to India i.e., Twenty Three percent (23%) of the last paid amount under the 2018 Agreement within four weeks.

              Our comment 

              The order establishes that SEP holders can ask the Court for the direction of a “Pro-tem security deposit” during the initial stages even when the matter is not dealt with in detail by the Court. On the point of prima facie infringement by Oppo, the Court importantly mentioned that an injunction can be secured, even if the infringement of one patent is established either prima facie or at the final stage. Thus, to restrain the sale of an infringing device, a Standard Essential Patent holder does not have to base its case on each of the thousands of patents that it owns and are used in the product; it can do so by showing that one or a handful of representative patents are infringed.

              The fact that the Court has the power to pass a pro-tem order without an exhaustive exploration of merits is a welcoming development in favour of the SEP holders.

              Find the right Legal Expert for your business

              The premier guide to leading legal professionals throughout the world

              Specialism
              Country
              Practice Area
              LAWYERS RECOGNIZED
              0
              EVALUATIONS OF LAWYERS BY THEIR PEERS
              0 m+
              PRACTICE AREAS
              0
              COUNTRIES AROUND THE WORLD
              0

              Join

              who are already getting the benefits
              0

              Sign up for the latest advisor briefings and news within Global Advisory Experts’ community, as well as a whole host of features, editorial and conference updates direct to your email inbox.

              Naturally you can unsubscribe at any time.

              Online Casino Reviews

            • Freeroll Poker Tournaments For Real Money
            • Australian Online Casino Real Money
            • Best Slot App To Win Real Money
            • Online Casino Real Money Australia
            • Best Paying Online Pokies
            • Wizard Of Oz Online Slots
            • All Slots Casino Mobile
            • Best Online Poker App Real Money
            • Best Online Casino To Play Roulette
            • Is Online Casino Legal
            • Online Casino That Accepts Paypal
            • Play Roulette For Real Money
            • Slot Apps To Win Real Money
            • Real Money Slots Online Usa
            • Safe Online Casino
            • Wizard Of Oz Slots
            • Real Online Pokies Nz
            • Biggest Online Casino In The World
            • Online Casino Pay With Paypal
            • Online Casino That Accept Paypal
            • Online Casino Canada Real Money
            • 3 Card Poker Online Real Money
            • Online Slots Real Money Canada
            • Best Online Poker Sites For Real Money
            • Real Money Poker App Android Usa
            • How To Make Money From Online Casino Bonuses
            • Real Money Poker App Iphone
            • How To Play Blackjack Online For Real Money
            • Best Slots To Play
            • Top 10 Online Pokies
            • Best Poker Apps Real Money
            • Online Casino Legal
            • Best Payout Online Casino Uk
            • Win Money Online Slots
            • Online Poker Nj Real Money
            • How To Win Online Slots
            • Casino Gaming License
            • Play Real Pokies Online
            • Blackjack Sites For Real Money
            • Real Money Casino Games For Android
            • Best New Online Slots
            • Flaming 777 Slots Games
            • Online Blackjack With Live Dealers
            • How To Play Online Slots
            • Facebook Casino Games Real Money
            • Online Casino With No Minimum Deposit
            • How To Beat Online Slots
            • Online Casino License
            • The Big Payback Slots
            • Royal Vegas Online Casino Withdrawal
            • Online Casino Minimum Deposit 5
            • Online Pokies Real Money Australia
            • Las Vegas Usa Online Casino
            • Real Money Poker App Android
            • Wheel Of Fortune Slots
            • Game Of Thrones Slots
            • Online Poker Real Money Usa Legal
            • Best Online Casino European Roulette
            • Blackjack Online Real Money Paypal
            • Online Video Poker Real Money Usa
            • How To Create An Online Casino
            • Lucky Nugget Online Casino Mobile
            • How To Withdraw Money From Online Casino
            • Platinum Play Online Casino Download
            • Online Casino For Usa Players
            • Best Online Casino Usa Real Money
            • Online Roulette Real Money Usa
            • Best Real Money Poker Sites
            • Android Slots Real Money
            • How To Start An Online Casino Business
            • How To Start An Online Casino
            • How To Start An Online Gambling Site
            • Best Online Casino For Blackjack
            • Play Baccarat Online For Money
            • Online Pokies New Zealand
            • Best Slots To Play At Golden Nugget
            • Slots Of Vegas Online Casino
            • Best Online Pokies Site
            • How To Beat Online Roulette
            • New Zealand Online Pokies
            • Online Poker Mobile Real Money
            • Which Online Slots Payout The Most
            • Is Online Casino Legal In India
            • Online Casino Software For Sale
            • Best Online Casino For Craps
            • Hard Rock Casino Slots
            • Win Real Money Online Pokies
            • Online Casino With Highest Payout Percentage
            • Poker Apps With Real Money
            • Online Roulette Real Money Review
            • Full Tilt Poker Real Money
            • Online Casino 5 Dollar Minimum Deposit
            • Online Roulette With Real Money
            • Best Online Roulette For Real Money
            • I Migliori Casino Online Italiani
            • Best Payout Online Slots
            • How To Play Baccarat Online
            • Play Casino Card Game Online
            • Play Blackjack Online For Real Money
            • Best Paying Online Slots
            • Casino License Cost
            • Online Poker Real Money California
            • Safe Online Casino Australia
            • Online Roulette Australia Real Money
            • Online Poker Real Money Texas
            • Online Roulette Real Money Paypal
            • Online Slots Australia Real Money
            • Golden Nugget Online Casino Review
            • Casino Games To Win Real Money
            • Online Pokies Australia Real Money
            • Online Gambling Blackjack Real Money
            • Win Real Money Playing Slots
            • How To Win Roulette Online
            • Aristocrat Pokies Online Real Money
            • Hollywood Casino Online Slots
            • Play Online Keno For Real Money
            • What's The Best Online Casino
            • Triple Double Diamond Slots
            • Play Roulette Online With Real Money
            • Roulette Online For Real Money
            • Play Roulette Online Real Money
            • Best Online Pokies Real Money
            • Big Red Pokies Online
            • How To Win At Online Blackjack
            • What Is The Best Online Roulette Site
            • Real Money Online Pokies
            • Spin To Win Slots
            • Ruby Slots Online Casino
            • Wheel Of Fortune Online Casino
            • Spin Palace Flash Casino Online
            • Online Poker Real Money App
            • Online Casino With Paypal Deposit
            • How To Win At Online Roulette
            • Can You Win Real Money On Slot Apps
            • Is Ignition Casino Safe
            • Online Casino Blackjack Real Money
            • Online Casino Win Real Money Usa
            • How To Make Money Online Casino
            • Online Casino Real Money Reviews
            • Slot Games To Win Real Money
            • Jackpot City Online Casino Download
            • Online Pokies Real Money
            • Casino War Online Real Money
            • Online Casino No Minimum Deposit
            • Play Wheel Of Fortune Slots Online
            • Best Online Casino Game To Win Money
            • Online Casino Without Wagering Requirements
            • Online Slots For Real Money Usa
            • Legal Online Casino Australia
            • How Do Online Slots Work
            • Best Online Casino For Us Players
            • Online Play Casino Roulette Game
            • Online Blackjack Real Money Australia
            • Real Casino Games Real Money Online
            • Online Slot Machines Real Money Paypal
            • The Best Online Casino For Roulette
            • What Online Casino Pays Out The Most
            • Start Your Own Online Casino
            • Legal Online Casino
            • Online Live Roulette Casino Game
            • Playing Blackjack Online For Real Money
            • Online Penny Slots Real Money
            • Best Online Blackjack For Money
            • How To Win Online Roulette
            • Real Money Poker Sites Usa
            • Best Time To Play Slots
            • Online Keno For Real Money
            • Best Payout Online Slots Uk
            • Online Slots Real Money Reviews
            • Best Online Pokies Nz
            • What States Allow Online Gambling
            • Best Real Money Poker App
            • Online Slots To Win Real Money
            • Real Money Slots App Iphone
            • Jackpot City Flash Casino Online
            • Ignition Casino Legit
            • All Star Slots Casino
            • How To Play Online Casino
            • Real Time Gaming Slots
            • Online Video Poker Real Money
            • How To Play Roulette Online For Money
            • How To Win On Online Slots
            • Age Of Gods Slots
            • Online Real Casino Money Games
            • Best Online Slots To Play
            • Online Poker California Real Money
            • Is Jackpot City Casino Legit
            • How To Win At Online Slots
            • Play Poker For Real Money
            • Safe Online Pokies Australia
            • Best Way To Play Slots
            • How To Play Casino Online
            • Play Online Roulette For Money
            • Online Casino Australia Real Money
            • Which States Allow Online Gambling
            • Play Keno Online Real Money
            • How To Win Online Blackjack
            • Online Blackjack With Real Dealers
            • How To Open Online Casino
            • What Are The Best Online Slots To Play
            • Big Win Casino Slots
            • Spin Palace Online Casino Australia
            • Best Slots To Win On
            • Casino Slots Win Real Money
            • Slots Magic Online Casino
            • Blackjack Online For Real Money
            • Slot Machine App Win Real Money
            • Online Casino Not Paying Out
            • Slots That Pay Out Real Money
            • Online Pokies Australia Reviews
            • Online Casino Minimum Deposit 1
            • Jackpot City Online Casino Review
            • Live Dealer Baccarat Online Casino
            • Online Casino Apps For Android
            • Online Casino Paypal Deposit Australia
            • Online Casino With Live Dealer
            • How To Play Blackjack Online
            • Slots To Win Real Money
            • Wheel Of Fortune Online Slots
            • Play Quick Hit Slots Online
            • Can You Count Cards In Online Blackjack
            • Palace Of Chance Online Casino
            • How To Play Roulette Online
            • Good Slots To Play
            • Which Online Casino Pays Out The Most
            • Heart Of Vegas Casino Slots
            • Best Online Casino For Canadians
            • Australian Online Pokies Real Money
            • Mohegan Sun Online Casino Nj
            • Online Casino Live Games Best Uk
            • Best Online Casino Australia Reviews
            • Play Pokies Online Real Money
            • Best Online Casino For Usa Players
            • How To Win Online Casino
            • Play Blackjack For Real Money
            • Best Slots On Bovada
            • Online Keno Real Money Usa
            • Online Slots Real Money Paypal
            • Best Poker Sites For Real Money
            • Safe Casino Sites
            • The Best Online Slots
            • Play Keno For Real Money
            • Real Online Pokies Australia
            • Queen Of The Nile Slots
            • Mummys Gold Casino Online Casino
            • Play Keno Online For Real Money
            • Best Poker Websites Real Money
            • Lucky Nugget Online Casino Download
            • Best Online Casino For Roulette
            • Play Roulette For Money Online
            • Video Slots Mobile Casino
            • Best Time To Play Online Slots
            • Best Real Money Online Poker
            • Play Blackjack Online With Friends
            • Play Baccarat Online For Real Money
            • Is Silver Oak Casino Legit
            • Big Fish Casino Real Money
            • Can You Win Real Money On Caesars Slots
            • Game Of Thrones Slots Casino
            • Best Online Slots Payout Percentage
            • Play Online Pokies For Real Money
            • Play Pokies Online Australia
            • High 5 Casino Real Slots
            • The Best Online Pokies
            • Online Pokies That Accept Paypal
            • Heart Of Vegas Slots
            • How To Play Online Roulette
            • Best Poker App Real Money
            • Best Online Casino Fast Payout
            • Best Slots At Wind Creek Casino
            • Online Casino 10 Minimum Deposit
            • Play Roulette Online For Money
            • Us Real Money Poker Sites
            • How To Win In Online Casino
            • Best Online Pokies Australia Review
            • Where To Play Roulette Online For Real Money
            • How To Beat Online Casino Slot Machines
            • Highest Payout Online Slots
            • Best Paying Online Casino Slots
            • Golden Tiger Online Casino Review
            • Online Casino With Live Dealers
            • Play Roulette Online For Real Money
            • Best Slots To Play At Casino
            • Slot Machine Games Win Real Money
            • Most Popular Online Casino Games
            • Casino Slots App Real Money
            • Online Casino Real Money Canada
            • Online Real Money Pokies
            • Online Roulette Game Real Money
            • Online Casino Roulette Real Money
            • Best Place To Play Roulette Online
            • Online Casino Book Of Ra Paypal
            • Online Blackjack With Real Money
            • Play Online Blackjack For Real Money
            • Is There A Slot Machine App For Real Money
            • Royal Vegas Online Casino App
            • Best Casino Slots To Play
            • Most Popular Online Slots
            • Best Way To Win At Slots
            • Slots You Can Win Real Money
            • Play Roulette Online Real Money Usa
            • Online Casino Real Money Paypal
            • Online Casino Australia Legal
            • Treasures Of Troy Slots
            • Online Casino For Us Players
            • Where Can I Play Blackjack Online For Real Money
            • Online Casino Paypal Book Of Ra
            • Online Roulette For Real Money
            • Best Online Blackjack Real Money
            • Poker App For Real Money
            • Jackpot Magic Slots Facebook
            • Best Online Casino Real Money Usa
            • Best Online Casino New Zealand
            • The Four Kings Casino And Slots
            • How To Play Slots Online
            • Best Online Pokies Australia
            • Usa Online Slots Real Money
            • Real Money Casino Android App
            • Online Slot Machines That Pay Real Money
            • Online Pokies Real Money Nz
            • Online Pokies Real Money App
            • Play Igt Slots Online
            • Best Casino Slots To Win Money
            • Online Casino Business For Sale
            • Play N Go Slots
            • Poker Apps For Real Money
            • Lucky Slots Real Money
            • All Slots Online Casino
            • Best Online Pokies Real Money Australia
            • Online Pokies Win Real Money
            • Best Online Casinos For Roulette
            • Pay Slots For Real Money
            • Best Online Poker Real Money
            • Slots App Win Real Money
            • Play Online Roulette For Real Money
            • Is Ignition Casino Legit
            • Wheel Of Fortune Slots Online
            • Lotsa Slots Real Money
            • Video Poker Online Real Money
            • Online Slots Usa Real Money
            • Play Blackjack Online Real Money
            • Jackpot City Online Pokies
            • Video Slots Online Casino
            • Is 888 Casino Legit
            • Online Slot Games That Pay Real Money
            • Prepaid Visa Card Online Casino
            • How To Stop Online Gambling
            • Best Slots To Play Online
            • Online Blackjack For Real Money
            • Slot Apps For Real Money
            • Mobile Slots Win Real Money
            • Newsletter Sign Up

              About Us

              Global Advisory Experts is dedicated to providing exceptional advisory services to clients around the world. With a vast network of highly skilled and experienced advisors, we are committed to delivering innovative and tailored solutions to meet the diverse needs of our clients in various jurisdictions.

              Contact Us

              Stay Informed

              Join Mailing List

              GAE